The Visit Shelburne and Lockport website seems to have the ultimate list of which places are worth checking out. According to them, the following are the winners (not neccessarily in order):

• Charlotte Lane Café 13 Charlotte Lane, Shelburne, Nova Scotia B0T 1W0, Canada
• Studio 138138 Water Street, Shelburne, NS B0T 1W0
• The Beandock Coffee & Collectibles10 John Street, Shelburne, Nova Scotia B0T 1W0, Canada
• The Ship’s Galley Pub & Eatery156 Water Street, Shelburne, Nova Scotia B0T 1W0, Canada
• Shelburne Café151 Water Street, Shelburne, Nova Scotia B0T 1W0, Canada